Practice Business

Psychology Today Referrals Dropping? What's Changed in 2026

Many therapists report far fewer Psychology Today contacts than a few years ago. Psychology Today says total contacts haven't fallen. What's likely happening, and what to do about it.

Arhaan Gupta

Arhaan Gupta

4 min read

Reviewed by Meir Flancbaum, PsyD on

Short answer: many therapists report far fewer Psychology Today contacts than a few years ago, while Psychology Today says its total contacts haven't materially changed. Both can be true. The same contacts are likely being split across many more profiles, including profiles run by therapy platforms. The fix is to measure where clients really come from and to build channels you control.

Where we stand: we make CoralEHR, an EHR for private-pay practices, and we build practice websites. We have no relationship with Psychology Today.

What therapists report

ClearHealthCosts collected reports from therapists in December 2025 and again in January 2026. One California marriage and family therapist went from a peak of 357 contacts in 2021 to 40 in 2025, and from about 32,000 search-result views in 2020 to about 2,600. Another wrote: "I used to get at least 5 month, 10 on a good month. Now it's like 1 every other month."

What Psychology Today says

Psychology Today told ClearHealthCosts it has seen no overall decline in directory visits and no material change in total contacts. It says "network affiliation does not influence ranking or placement" and that it doesn't prioritize profiles based on who pays for them.

What's likely going on

More profiles share the same searches. Platforms such as Grow, Rula and Alma have offered to take over therapists' profiles. ClearHealthCosts reports that Grow will own and maintain a therapist's profile, and a therapist who opts out keeps a separate one, so the same person can appear twice. Alma ran a pilot reimbursing members for a profile. One psychologist said it "felt like three-quarters" of the profiles he clicked said "managed by Rula" or another platform.

Other routes reach people first. Insurer apps and paid search send people to marketplaces. When we searched "trauma therapist Denver who takes Aetna" and similar phrases in November 2026, Headway, Zocdoc and SonderMind pages built for each insurer and city filled most results.

Unauthorized listings add noise. Behavioral Health Business reported in November 2025 on directories that list therapists without their consent, some with more than 100,000 profiles.

Five things to do now

  1. Measure it. Add a tag to the website link on your profile (for example ?utm_source=psychology-today&utm_medium=directory) and ask every new client how they found you. In a few months you'll know what the $29.95 buys.
  2. Find your duplicates. Search the directory for your name. If a platform runs a second profile you don't want, ask it to take it down.
  3. Make the profile specific. Your fee, who you see most, how soon you can start and a real photo. Those are what people use to choose, and they're what AI assistants and search engines check against your website.
  4. Build what you control. Referral relationships with doctors and colleagues were the top client source therapists named in Heard's 2026 survey (83%). A website with a page for each specialty you treat, your fee and one clear way to book is the other.
  5. Answer fast. In an October 2026 JAMA Health Forum study of 5,822 calls to listed mental health clinicians, 61% got no real answer. Wherever people find you, a quick reply wins.

If you're on a platform too

Platforms can bring clients, and some charge for it. Headway now takes $9.99 per session for the life of any client who found you through its directory, while clients who book through your own link are exempt. We cover the details in Headway's $9.99 fee vs Grow Therapy.

Where CoralEHR fits

Three of the five steps above are things our software and websites handle:

  • Measuring it. Every booking request in CoralEHR records how the person found you, whether that's Psychology Today, your website, Google, an AI assistant or a colleague. Owners see new clients and first sessions by source, month by month.
  • A channel you control. We build practice websites with a page for each specialty you treat, written in your clients' words, with your fee high on the page and one clear way to book. They're built for Google, its AI Overviews and assistants like ChatGPT and Claude. You own the domain and the content.
  • Answering fast. Website booking requests land in CoralEHR, ready to confirm, instead of in an inbox.

CoralEHR doesn't replace a directory profile. Many people still search directories, and a complete profile that matches your website helps search engines and AI assistants trust your details.

See how CoralEHR websites work.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

Why am I getting fewer Psychology Today referrals?

Many therapists report steep drops since 2021. Psychology Today says total directory visits and contacts haven't materially changed. The most likely explanation is that the same contacts are split across more profiles, including profiles managed by platforms such as Grow Therapy and Rula, while insurer apps and paid search send people to marketplaces.

Is a Psychology Today profile still worth $29.95 a month?

For many therapists, yes, but measure it. Tag the website link on your profile so your EHR or analytics can tell those visitors apart, and ask new clients how they found you. A complete profile also helps when AI assistants and search engines check your details.

Can Grow Therapy create a Psychology Today profile for me?

According to ClearHealthCosts, Grow will own and maintain a therapist's Psychology Today profile, and a therapist who opts out can keep a separate profile, which means there will be two. Search the directory for your own name and ask the platform to remove any duplicate you don't want.

What is the best alternative to Psychology Today for getting clients?

Referrals from other providers and your own website. In Heard's 2026 survey, 83% of therapists named referrals and word of mouth as a client source and 82% named directories. Specialty directories such as EMDRIA, IOCDF and Postpartum Support International reach people who already know what they need.

Can my own website replace Psychology Today?

For some practices, over time, but most keep both. A directory reaches people who are browsing; your own site reaches people searching for your specialty and checking you before they book. Tag the link on your profile and ask new clients how they found you, so you can see which one brings clients.

Share
Arhaan Gupta

Arhaan Gupta

Co-founder and CEO, CoralEHR

I co-founded CoralEHR, an EHR for private-pay therapy practices, and I set up every new practice with them myself.

LinkedIn

Stay Updated with CoralEHR Blog

Get the latest insights on modern healthcare solutions, practice management, and therapy workflows delivered to your inbox.

Run your whole practice in one place

Try CoralEHR free

The private-pay EHR for behavioral health: notes, scheduling, telehealth, payments and a client portal, with AI when you want it. Free 2-week trial, no credit card.